California's Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) tried for more than three years to get me to sign a "stipulated agreement" that harmless filing errors in 2013 when I was a first-time state candidate, mistakes such as late-mailing the paper hardcopies of campaign finance reports that had already been filed electronically, were violations of the law meriting thousands of dollars in fines.

FPPC lawyers demanded that I agree to this "settlement offer" or face worse, at one point holding out the possibility of $55,000 in fines if I did not sign the stipulation agreement.

But I don't agree with this at all, because my campaign substantially complied with the law and I made a good-faith effort throughout, which they acknowledged themselves, in writing, in 2017:



FPPC admits there was a good-faith effort and substantive compliance with the law


The FPPC's proposed "stipulated agreement" required me to give up my right to due process of law, and I wouldn't do that. I asked for a hearing. It was held on June 19, 2019, at 9:00 a.m. at the Office of Administrative Hearings. You can read the briefs, the arguments and the transcript at www.ReformPoliticalReform.com. You can also read the judge's proposed decision, and judge for yourself whether there is any justice in recommending a fine of -- ready? -- $12,500, given the facts of this case.

This matter will be on the FPPC's agenda at the October 18 meeting in Sacramento for a final decision.

Because I did not sign the "stipulated agreement" that required me to waive my rights, I still have the right to appeal. 

It will be expensive to go to court, and if you would like to help with a donation of $10, $25 or $50, your support would be much appreciated. Thank you.

With all good wishes to you and your family, and hopes for a better future in California,


Susan Shelley

Contribution Amount

Personal Information

  • Required
  • Required
  • Required

  • Required
  • Required
  • Required
  • Required

Employment Information

  • Required
  • Required

Payment Information

Billing Information

Your donation will appear on your credit card or bank statement as "RP*"


By clicking submit you agree to our refund policy in our terms of service.



Legal info: Donations made here go to the Susan Shelley for Assembly 2014 campaign committee (FPPC ID #1355796), which the FPPC has advised in writing may be used to pay expenses connected with this matter. "GoFundMe" and similar types of fundraising are not permitted, according to the FPPC. Because this is a donation to a campaign committee, I am required by law to ask for your name, address, occupation and employer. (If retired, please list that as both an occupation and employer.) This committee is still open because I made loans to it, but your contribution for legal expenses will NOT be used to retire debt without your express permission. In accordance with the law, donations from any one individual totaling in excess of $8,200 to the 2014 Susan Shelley for Assembly committee ($4,100 for the June primary and $4,100 for the November general election) will be returned due to being over the contribution limit set by law. Please also note that as a journalist, I will return contributions that could create the appearance of a conflict of interest. Thank you.

Paid for by Susan Shelley for Assembly 2014. ID #1355796


Piryx - The Social Giving Platform

Now fundraising is as easy as writing a blog or posting a status update and can be integrated into your website, product or mobile app. With Piryx, causes raise money online in more volume and much more effectively across the web. To learn more and create your own free account visit Piryx.com.